Saturday, January 5, 2013

500 Lumen Gear Review - Defying the Dark


I hadn't planned on doing a review of this piece of gear, until I actually used it (why the picture above has it already opened with the batteries in it).

It was given to me by friends to have on hand in my crash pad in case of a storm. For a full fledged disaster kit I'd go with  headlamp light with low power LED's and the energizer solar 9-LED lantern light. But for something inexpensive to have in a couple of rooms or in the truck as a back up, for $20?  Yes! What a perfect little gift!

The Defiant LED 550 Lumen Flashlight.  From Home Depot.

Lights are fun, but we often don't think about them until the power is off and we just discovered that grocery store cheap plastic flashlight has all the candle power of a  microwaved corn dog.

And though the Jedi Pocket knives are fun to demonstrate The Force while you watch Star Wars in your Princess Leia bathrobe with the dog, they DON'T have much illumination power.


So you want to find something else to have on hand, even as a BUF (not to be confused with an aircraft known as BUFF, which WILL light up your sky).  One sometimes want a flashlight that's inexpensive enough you can have one in the truck, in the bathroom, by the door, for the wife, for the dog (scratch that, you'd be woken up with a 500 Lumen spotlight in your face by someone that wants a Scooby Snack at 4 a.m).

You aren't going to chase down a bad guy with this, or go spelunking, you simply want an inexpensive bright  flashlight that won't break if you drop it on the floor, that will light up what you need to see, and stay lit up for a couple hours, while you fetch the dog that ran after the squirrel, or find that box in the basement after the ceiling light quits.

We'll start with the obvious.  Brightness.  These pictures were taken with my ultra cheap truck glove box camera, so there is no help with aperture to make the picture look "brighter". This is a large,  pitch black room with heavy insulated  curtains.  Its' darker than the inside of Barkley's stomach with the lights off as I sometimes have to sleep during the day.

I turned on the flashlight, pointing up so not to hurt Barkley's eyes.

I've seen Sherpa landing lights that weren't as bright.

Here it is in the guest bath after dark with the same cheap camera.  If my power went out in a 4 a.m. morning storm, this would be more than enough to get dressed, showered and ready, including tactical lip gloss.

CON's

This is not a dainty flashlight.

It will NOT hide in your pocket without attracting unwanted attention.  It is a heavy flashlight, (even being aluminum) but that is a given considering the length.  But it's not one you can just toss in your little evening bag to take with you.  This is a "big storm, the power just went out" or "Honey, the zombies are eating the raccoons that were raiding our garbage can"  flashlight.

Made in China. 

PRO's

There's only one mode to the switch. Oscar November and Oscar Foxtrot Foxtrot.   Handy when it's dark and you just need to turn it on, and quickly.

The light is bright, almost pure white, very little yellow to it (you'll see the yellow in ultra cheapo LED lights).  As far as light goes,  it's a good throw with a usable spill.  I'm not sure it's quite the 800 feet advertised (600 anyway) but  it's much brighter than the small conventional flashlight you might have around the house and seriously brighter than most C and D cell flashlights. 

The construction is sturdy and solid for the price. The connections are tight due to decent threading and O rings (yes, I autopsied it).  The lens is pretty cheap plastic, the lens/reflector held in by a ring that will thread down pretty tight (and watch your fingers as there are some sharp edges). This flashlight is equipped with a Cree XM-L LED on a 20mm star board with the head threading into the midsection that acts as the heat sink and houses the emitter/driver that is a stand alone unit. The emitter appeared to be glued down and was pretty solid.

One unexpected feature is the green glow-in-the-dark lens gasket. Sure it looks cool but I'm not sure what purpose it serves and if you were to need to turn off the light suddenly so you are invisible to a threat, it's going to be visible in the dark briefly.  Sure it's handy for a couple of minutes if you turn off, then drop the flashlight in the dark, but when trying to be tactical, it might not be a feature you want.

It states it's good for 4 hours.  It uses 3 inexpensive C batteries, unlike most other 500+ lumen flashlights.  At 4000mAH (LSD) or 5000mAH (HSD), C cells are pretty high in capacity. So although I have not tested the  "four hour" use statement, the light should have a pretty good run of a couple of hours at least.

If you're going to use it a lot you might invest  invest in some Tenergy Premium rechargeable C cells and a charger for them.  Even though C cells are cheap, they're not free.

 Lifetime warranty it states on the packaging, although the Home Depot website says one year. 

There are certainly better built flashlights, and those are usually made in America, but where are you going to find  a C cell powered XM-L light for $20?  Flashlights this powerful from the top brands that are marketed to military and law enforcement units can run well over three hundred bucks. For those that don't wish to pay more for that type of quality, or can't with a tight budget, this is a good find. Plus it's cheap enough you don't mind it getting banged up a little.  Think of it it as a drop light without the cord.

Oh, and it's waterproof (unlike my last cell phone which got knocked off  of the counter into Barkley's water bowl).


22 comments:

The Freeholder said...

Better watch out--you'll wind up over on the Candlepower Forums with the rest of us flashlight geeks. ;-)

Rev. Paul said...

I'd wondered about that one. Thanks for checking it out & then letting us know.

The Donald said...

Cool! Last year, I paid about the same or a bit more for a tri-mode Browning 2AA with only 125 lumens.

That 500 lumens will send the dark running. And, as a guy, I suppose I don't care if it 'prints' while it's in my pocket, or allows me to kinda balance things out (uh, yeah, I wish...).

greg said...

I'll have to keep an eye out for that in the stores. For Christmas, my wife got me a rechargeable spotlight measured in millions of candlepower, but that looks like a lot of lumens for a little cash.

I'm a big believer that you can never have enough lights or knives.

Erin Palette said...

500 Lumens for $20 is amazing.

I still need to review the Kel-Tec 420 lumen flashlight (which IS small enough to fit in a handbag, thank you, but is far far pricier) and this article will make a helpful counterpoint to that.

Keads said...

Great info. Surefire stuff is expensive and the old school Mag Lights are a bit cumbersome.

BUFF's will indeed light stuff up, but I have found them REALLY expensive to run =)

Ken said...

...too stubborn to give up my maglites...

Jerry said...

The LED flashlights are pretty amazing. I bought a Nebo Red-Line for $30 at my local reloading store. 220 Lumens is quite usable with a focusing lens. This is more lumens than my 5 cell Maglite but at a fraction of the size & weight.

The Red-Line feature is OK as a night light but distracting otherwise; I slipped a piece of shrink tubing over the red line feature.

I especially like that the Red Line has three illumination levels, an SOS flash and a strobe flash. It runs 4 hours on maximum illumination with 3 AAA batteries; longer on the other modes.

Once Free Man said...

Lumen/$ ratio is certainly a bargain, but too big for almost anything and everything I need a light to help, especially night trail rides on the MTB.
A purported 4000 lumen headlamp will be delivered today. I'll see whether it's more like 40 when it arrives.

Monkeywrangler said...

As a confirmed Flashaholic I applaud your dissection of that light! I don't have any C-cell lights any more, but do have Lambda custom 3D build in a 2D M@g body. It puts out somewhere around 700+ lumens OTF on fresh cells and is 3-mode L-M-H.

All my other lights tend toward either 18650 single cell lights or 1xCR123 LiFePO4 rechargeable batteries. I am fond of the Eagletac D25c Mini, and the Olight i1EOS.

Vic303

immagikman said...

I love that flash light, it is exactly what you need in a storm :)
However I've found that if you have Natural Gas available in your area a whole house Generator 10kw to 17KW cannot be beat. If you figure in all the expenses incurred with Disaster preparedness food restocking, batteries lights etc and you live in an area with frequent power loss they are well worth the expense. They can run off Propane tanks too but, the idea was to get away from having to store lots of flamable material on site. Also loved the reference to the BUFF :) as Keads said, they are a tad spendy to operate :)

Old NFO said...

Nice, but I'm not going to run out and replace all my MagLites... And Barkley gets the TUB as his water bowl??? :-P

Uno Mas (SASS #80082) said...



This is the AR-15 of flashlights: none to be found.



And after burying a Dodge Lambcharger up to the door sills in an ol' Mechico bog during the blackest night I've ever (not) seen, I'm a diehard flashlight geek.

Stormdrane said...

Excellent review! I'll have to look for one the next time I get to the Home Depot. I do like bright/inexpensive flashlights. 8)

Brigid said...

Freeholder - :-=)

Rev Paul - I still have my maglights but for the price this would be a great add on.

greg - lights, knives, yes.

Erin - I look forward to your review, they are always outstanding.

Keads - thanks for a much needed smile.


drjim said...

Bummer!

SOLD OUT both online, and in the stores.

I'll keep my eyes peeled for one the next time I go to HD.

Carteach said...

Looks like an interesting unit, and I will watch for it should I visit the store.

I favor a Fenix for everyday carry. Not even teenage boys can destroy it.

Doom said...

Thanks a bunch for the heads up. I've been looking for something a bit better and more practical. My AA flashlights, of course, don't do it. And I can't remember how many various C and D flashlights I have looked at or tried. I'm going to grab some before they stop making those, lower the quality somehow, or... Gah!

fast richard said...

This was my year for flashlight upgrades. I bought one that runs on lithium rechargeables salvaged from laptop battery packs. It is very bright. http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005E48K6I/ref=oh_details_o07_s00_i00

I also bought little key chain sized Fenix lights for everyone in the family for Christmas(Mom, brothers, sisters-in-law, nieces, nephews, daughter, etc). A little AAA light these days gives as much light as the old mini maglite or the Tekna-lite 2 that was my favorite flashlight until the bulbs became hard to find.

Will said...

Doom:

check at Costco for their 3-pack of LED flashlights.
Tactical black, supposed to be somewhere around 160-200 Lumens. Run on 3 AAA batts. Under $20. Tough units, I dropped one out a second story window onto concrete. Bent a bit of the crenelation around the lens, but no other damage, and still works. Tail switch: med, high, strobe, off.

Ad absurdum per aspera said...

> check at Costco for their 3-pack
> of LED flashlights.

TechLite Lumen Master 200, $18.95 if memory serves. Somebody put up video of them:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rpjGP1a32PY

My only regret about that purchase was not waiting a month until they came on a $2.50 instant rebate. (Generally speaking, if you want the best possible buy at Costco, watch what I buy, then wait a few weeks for the next coupon book.)

Made in China.

Not much of a club but a pretty good fistload, and a lot easier to have with you than a 4-D-cell Maglite. Has a wrist strap so you don't drop it into whatever part of your car you're inspecting. Seems quite sturdy.

If I could change one thing, it'd be the order of events when you push the button: in a hairy situation I'd rather have the high beams first.

The "strobe" mode might be good for roadside safety, as it is very attention getting and unlikely to be mistaken for anything else. I guess it to be 10-12 Hz.

It says "200" on the barrel; details of its actual output, I'll leave to the photogoniometer enthusiasts, but it's pretty bright. Not like high end tactical stuff, but then, it doesn't suck down expensive specialty batteries in a big hurry like they do, or used to, either.

Costco's website doesn't show this model anymore, though they have some other high output flashlights by this and other companies. Note: they carry lots of things that are not on the website, not at just every store, or not available at all times.

High power LEDs are getting pretty amazing in terms of not only output but efficiency. One thing that is still in early days is bright, even, near-omnidirectional light (i.e., a good replacement for the household incandescent bulb) at a popular price, and even that is just a matter of time.

I'd bet that in a few years, the compact fluorescent bulb will be a transitional technology on its way out, and LEDs -- safer, more efficient, long lived -- will be the mainstream source of light for a great many things.

Anyway, I'd call that Lumen Master 200 from Costco less than perfect for tactical stuff but one heck of a value for the money, and would buy it again. Preferably on a coupon. :)

Brigid said...

Thanks everyone for sharing all the good information with each other!